Wet n wild eyeliner in "baby got black":  $1.50 @ Dollarama (RSP:  $1.99)

I remember these used to be a dollar, so I held off  on getting this.  Turns out they're $2 everywhere else so I went back and got this one!

The reviews are good, plus it's almost twice as long as most other pencils that are around twice the price or more.