Essence smokey eye pencil:  $2.29 (RSP:  $3.99)
Essence kajal pencil in teddy:  $1.19 (RSP:  $1.99)
Essence extreme lasting eye pencil:  $2.29 (RSP:  $3.99)

All @ Shopper's drug mart.

Also got a white kajal pencil for $1.19 previously.  It seems like these items are being clearanced, but I've seen different selections at different locations.